North Carolina mother who vanished 24 years ago reunites with daughter

By MELISSA KOENIG, US REPORTER 02:57 27 Mar 2026, updated 10:14 27 Mar 2026

A North Carolina mother-of-three who vanished more than 24 years ago had an emotional reunion with her daughter as she now faces charges for a crime she committed back in 2001. 

Michelle Hundley Smith was just 38 when she failed to return home after going to K-Mart in Martinsville, Virginia to go Christmas shopping on December 9, 2001.

But her daughter, Amanda, 39, never gave up hope in finding out what had happened to her mother, running a Facebook page asking for information and sharing reflections on missing her mother.

It has since been revealed that about one month before Hundley Smith's disappearance, on November 11, 2001, she received a citation for driving while intoxicated. 

When she then failed to attend a court hearing on December 27, 2001, three weeks after she disappeared, a warrant was issued for her arrest.

The break in the case finally came last month, when local sheriffs followed a tip and tracked Hundley Smith down to a trailer park in St. Pauls, North Carolina, a two-and-a-half-hour drive from where she went missing in Stoneville.

Days later, Hundley Smith, now 62, was arrested on an outstanding order relating to her failure to appear in court all those years ago.

When she then prepared to face a judge for the crime at the Rockingham County district courthouse on Thursday, she reunited with the daughter who pledged to support her through this difficult time.

The emotional scene was caught on camera, showing the moment Hundley Smith noticed her daughter across the street and started running over to her, with both of their arms wide open. 

The two then shared a long, tight embrace during which Hundley Smith was seen stroking her daughter's hair before they headed into the courthouse together.

'It was weird. It was wild. It was emotional,' Amanda told WFMY of the reunion. 'I ran up to her, hugged her and we cried a little.'

She added that she knows 'everything is not black and white. There's a whole gray area.' But, she told WXII: 'Life's too short for me to hold a grudge against her because she's my mom.

'We only get one life and I want my mom in it,' she said, before accompanying her mother to the arraignment at which she requested a court-appointed attorney.

The two then left court in the same vehicle, WXII reports. 

Following the shocking discovery that her mother had been found, Amanda posted a lengthy statement on the Facebook page dedicated to finding her. 

'As far as my opinions and feelings on my mom...I am ecstatic, I am p***ed, I am heartbroken, I am all over the map! Will I have a relationship once more with my mom? Honestly I can't answer that because I don't even know,' she wrote.

'My initial reaction would be "Yes absolutely," but then I think of all the hurt...But even then, my mom is only human just as we all are,' Amanda continued.

'When my mom was a part of my daily life, she showed me a love and bond that will never ever be forgotten. There were mother-daughter arguments of course, but right now all I can remember are the smiles we shared, the times together that were happy and the love I felt!'

'My dad has been in my daily life all of my life, and he shows me love and we have a life that will never be forgotten! There were father-daughter arguments as well but all I remember are the smiles we have, the love I feel and the bond we share!

'Both my dad and my mom deserve to have their choices and their feelings respected as well.' 

Amanda was the only one of her siblings who attended the hearing, saying her family agreed to make individual decisions about the type of relationship they would have with Hundley Smith.

Her brother, Randal, previously told the Daily Mail he does not want to reconnect with his mother, whom he considers to be a 'stranger.'

'She's been gone this long, and for someone to meet my children is a privilege in my eyes,' said Randal, a happily-married father-of-two.

'That's not one she deserves.'

He added that he is not 'angry with her because that's a wasted emotion, but I really don't have any emotions,' he said. 'But I don't wish her any ill.'

In the end, Randal, who was just nine years old when his mother disappeared, said his life 'turned out good' even though he had to 'grow up early.'

'I learned to become self-sufficient, and I think it turned me into who I am,' the now-33-year-old said.

'I'm sure our lives would have been a little more normal if she stayed around. But overall, I'm happy with how mine turned out.'

For her part, Smith told the Daily Mail from her home in St. Pauls, 80 miles south of the state capital Raleigh, that she had never realized how long her family had spent looking for her after she walked out on them.

She said that at the time she disappeared she believed her husband and three kids were better off without her.

She insisted she had not abandoned her children and she had left them with their father as she was not in the 'mental state' to care for them.

After Hundley Smith left the family, she met a truck driver named Randy Johnson on the Texas/Arkansas border, and lived with him in his 18-wheeler on the road, mainly traveling the West Coast. 

But in 2013, the pair returned to North Carolina.

She said Johnson had never pressed her for details about her past, but eventually, she said: 'I just told him what I went through.'

Johnson died in November 2024 and Hundley Smith is now due back in court on April 23.